How To: Sew Cast Iron Handle Covers

Since incorporating more cast iron skillets into my cooking routine, I have quickly realized the need for a handle cover. Cast iron handles can become extremely hot, even with stovetop cooking. I also needed something to protect my family from burns if we were serving buffet style in the kitchen. Instead of ordering a handle cover, I looked at my pile of fabric and decided I could easily make one, as well as customize the size and colors to each pan.

Materials:

  • 2 pieces of main fabric (I used 4in x 7in)
  • 2 pieces of lining fabric (same size)
  • 2 pieces of Insulbrite, or any other heat protecting batting (same size)
  • Matching thread
  • Sewing pins or clips
  • Sewing machine or hand stitching needle
  • Scissors

Instructions:

  • Use your cast iron pan to roughly determine how big your fabric needs to be cut. You need approximately a 1.5 inch border of fabric around where the handle sits. I made my fabric 4×7 inches, and that ended up being a perfect size for my main 12 inch skillet.
  • Cut all of your fabric to the size you need. You will need 2 main fabric pieces, 2 lining pieces, and 2 insulation pieces. I used the same fabric for the lining, but you can use two different patterns if you prefer.
  • Round the corners on one end of each piece of material.
  • Separate the materials out into two groups. In each group, you will need 1 of your main fabric pieces, 1 of your lining fabric pieces, and 1 of your insulation pieces.
  • Sandwich the main fabric and the lining fabric right sides together.
  • Place the two fabric pieces on top of your insulation piece, placing your main fabric up against the insulation.
The stack should be insulation, then your main fabric, then your lining fabric; ensuring the main fabric and lining fabric are right sides together.
  • Sew a basting stitch along the straight end of the fabric stack. Make sure to back stitch a bit at the beginning and end.
  • Repeat with your other group of fabric.
  • Open up each grouping of fabric so the lining piece is branching one direction, and the main fabric and insulation pieces are still together branching the other way.
  • Stack the two groups of fabric right sides together.
  • Pin around the entire stack with pins or clips.
  • Sew around the outside of the stack, leaving approximately 2 inches open along the straight edge of the lining side. Make sure your needle is going through all layers of fabric, and you backstitch at the beginning and end.
  • Use the area you did not sew to turn the entire project inside out. I found it easiest to start feeding the insulated side through the hole first.
  • Pinch the hole in the fabric together and stitch closed.
  • Push the lining down into the insulated end.
  • Slide your new handle cover onto your cast iron skillet!

NOTES:

  • Do not use any projects containing Insulbrite in the microwave. Insulbrite contains metal.
  • Handle covers are not oven proof. They are only meant to slide on and off of skillets when cooking or serving on the stovetop or transferring in and out of the oven.
  • Handle covers can be washed with soap and water and air dried.

Leave a comment

I’m Shelby

Welcome to The Gentle Harvest! I’m a wife, mom to a sweet toddler, and a Registered Nurse on a journey to embrace a slower, more intentional life. In the midst of the fast-paced world we live in, I’ve found joy in the simple things—gardening, canning, sewing, and baking.

This blog was born out of my desire to document my journey toward a more holistic, peaceful way of living while connecting with other moms who long for the same. Here, you’ll find inspiration for slowing down, practical tips for a simple home, and encouragement to savor the little moments in motherhood.

If you’re looking for a community of like-minded women who want to embrace a life of simplicity and intention, you’re in the right place. Let’s create a space where we can share, learn, and support each other on this journey.

I’m so glad you’re here!

Let’s connect